karl wrote:
Price: I bought the HPI at a steep discount in 2009, Minichamps in 1994 = tie
Packaging: colorful outer box + easy to unscrew persplex box = tie
Body: no 1:1 to compare to, but both seem to be exact copies of each other in body size and shape = tie
Paint/decals: very similar, is the paint a bit thicker on the Minichamps? Or just the HPI has a slightly crisper casting? Not obviously different = HPI: *
Wheels: HPI: ** less plasticy, great brakes behind spokes
Exterior details: HPI: ** Are silver metal antennas correct? Front and rear more detailed, fantastic exhaust, tow hooks!!!; Minichamps looks more fake at the rear as the heat shields are a little off-angle.
Interior: HPI: ** Color on the seatbelts and hoses, better shaped racing seat. Both have similar rollcages.
Hey, there's a new 'thank you' button... works great

Well, I wanted to thank you for the comparison. Some of your high marks are for the same things I've noticed about HPI: the tow hooks, the exhaust and the brakes - real excellence. I finally managed to sell a HPI-model today, after 2 months of trying

I really don't think people realize what they're missing. On another model site (I know you're a member there), there was a questionnaire: who are the best 1/43 model makers of today. I think at least 50% had HPI high on their lists, and overall they tied for first place with Spark and Minichamps.